How to Compare Two Business Insurance Proposals
Two proposals can show similar totals while covering different things. Put them side by side on the same few lines before you decide, and ask the agent to explain every difference.
Line up the same coverage for the same business
First confirm both proposals describe the same operations, locations, payroll, vehicles and revenue. If the inputs differ, the prices are not comparable. Ask each agency to correct its application rather than comparing as-is.
Compare these items, in order
- Policies included: which coverages each proposal contains, and which you asked for but did not get.
- Limits: per-occurrence and aggregate amounts, and any sub-limits.
- Deductibles and retentions: what you pay before the policy responds.
- Exclusions and conditions: ask for the sections that matter for your work in plain language.
- Insurer: name the company that will actually issue each policy.
- Billing and audit: down payment, installments and whether premium can change after an audit.
- Service: who issues certificates and how claims are reported.
Ask each agent the same follow-up questions
What is the cheapest change that would reduce the premium, and what coverage would I give up? What would make this quote change before binding? Is anything in the proposal subject to later underwriting approval?
Decide on coverage fit first, price second
If one proposal omits a coverage your contract requires, it is not the cheaper option, it is an incomplete one. When the two are equivalent in substance, then compare price and service.