Insurance Agent vs. Broker: Independent, Captive and What to Ask
The words agent, broker, independent and captive describe relationships, not quality. They are also used loosely, and the legal meaning can differ from one state to the next. Ask the questions below rather than relying on a label.
What the labels usually mean
- Captive agent: typically sells for one insurance company or one company group.
- Independent agent or agency: typically holds appointments with several insurance companies and can place a client with any of them.
- Broker: commonly used for a firm that places coverage on behalf of the buyer, often including specialty or hard-to-place risks. Some states define "broker" in law and some use the word differently, so check your state insurance department's terminology.
Why this directory does not label agencies by type unless they say so
An agency calling itself independent on its own website is a statement we can cite. Anything beyond that, such as a specific list of carrier appointments, is shown only when the agency publishes it. If a profile says nothing, that means the information was not published where we looked, not that the answer is no.
Questions to ask on the first call
- Which insurance companies can you place my business with, and do you work with more than one?
- How are you paid on this policy: commission, a fee, or both?
- Are you licensed in my state, and what is your license number?
- Who handles service after I buy: certificates, changes, claims?
- If you cannot place my risk with your carriers, will you tell me, and will you refer me elsewhere?
How to use the answers
A single-company agent can be a good fit when that company writes your type of business at a price and service level you like. A multi-carrier agent can compare more options. Neither guarantees a lower price or better claims handling; compare the proposals themselves.