Insurance Agency Guide

Switching Malpractice Insurers: Claims-Made, Occurrence and Tail

You are about to change malpractice insurers: a new carrier, a new group program, or a move from a claims-made to an occurrence form. The risky part is not the new policy. It is the handoff. With a claims-made policy, coverage depends on when a claim is made and reported, so the day the old policy ends can leave years of past patient care with nothing behind it. This guide gives you a timeline to work through, the clauses to find in a real specimen policy, and questions to put in writing before you cancel anything.

Published by Insurance Agency Guide editorial. Reviewed Nov 18, 2026. Sources are listed at the end.

The two ways a policy decides whether you are covered

An occurrence policy responds to events that happen while the policy is in force, even if the claim arrives years later. A claims-made policy responds to claims that are made (and, in many forms, reported to the insurer) while the policy or an extended reporting period is in force. The specimen policy opened for this guide is titled “Claims-Made and Reported” and says it applies to claims first made and reported during the policy period or an applicable extended reporting period (Curi specimen policy, form IAMPLC01 01.2025).

That difference is why a switch needs a plan. Leaving an occurrence policy generally leaves the past covered by the old policy. Leaving a claims-made policy does not, unless something replaces it. For the general comparison across professions, see our professional liability guide.

Three terms that decide the handoff

TermWhat it meansWhat to ask
Prior acts date (also called retroactive date)The earliest date from which care can lead to a covered claim. In the specimen, the insuring agreement requires the medical incident to take place on or after the Prior Acts Date.What is the date on my current policy, and will the new policy use the same date, or start it fresh?
Extended reporting period (ERP, “tail”)Extra time to report claims after a claims-made policy ends, for care that happened before it ended.Is it offered, for how long, when must I elect it, and how is it priced?
Prior acts coverage (“nose”)A new claims-made policy that reaches back to your old prior acts date instead of starting fresh.Will the new insurer give me full prior acts credit, and in writing?

You generally need one of two things after you leave a claims-made policy: a tail from the old insurer, or prior acts coverage from the new one. Who supplies it, and who pays, is a contract question, not a given.

What a real specimen policy says about tail

One example: the Curi specimen medical professional liability policy for physicians, form IAMPLC01 (01.2025). It is a specimen, not a policy anyone holds, and its own cover page says state amendatory endorsements are not included and that the issued policy governs. Use it to see what clauses look like, not to learn your rights. Section XII, Extended Reporting Period, shows the kinds of terms to look for in your own policy:

  • Who may buy it. If the policy is non-renewed or cancelled for a reason other than non-payment, the policyholder may buy an unlimited ERP for all insureds, and an individual whose coverage ends has the right to buy one for themselves.
  • A deadline. The ERP must be requested and paid for within sixty days of the coverage ending.
  • Pricing rule. The premium follows the rules and rates in place on the ERP’s effective date and is fully earned at that date. The specimen states no amount.
  • Replacement coverage cuts it off. The ERP does not apply to a claim covered by a policy that takes effect on or after the cancellation or non-renewal date. So a new policy that picks up the claim can change what the tail is for.
  • No-additional-premium ERPs. While the policy is in force, an individual insured can receive an ERP at no additional premium on death, permanent disability, retirement or after a stated age and years insured. The retirement and age rules carry conditions (for example, a written request within thirty days of the coverage ending).

Notice that the sixty-day and thirty-day windows are short. They are the first thing to put on your calendar.

A state example: what regulators require

Tail rules for medical liability vary by state, so do not assume your state matches this one. As one example, the Texas Department of Insurance’s review checklist for medical professional liability forms says a claims-made form must carry a prominent disclosure, give the insured at least an automatic 30-day extended reporting period, allow at least thirty days to buy the extended reporting endorsement, make a term of at least one year available, and make an unlimited extended period available (TDI: Review Requirements Checklist, Medical Professional Liability). That checklist is about what filed forms must contain in Texas; it is not a statement of your rights elsewhere.

New York is a useful contrast. Its Insurance Department issued an opinion that applied the state’s Regulation 121 free-tail rule only to a physician who retires permanently and totally from practice, and found that a physician who left private practice but still works full time in a hospital did not qualify (NY OGC Opinion 02-10-24). Check your own state’s insurance department for current rules, and ask your agent which state endorsement is attached to your policy.

Timeline worksheet for a practice switching insurers

The dates below are hypothetical, built around a policy that ends on the last day of a month. Replace them with the dates and deadlines in your own policy.

WhenStepGet in writing
About 90 to 120 days before the end dateAsk your current insurer or broker how to read your policy’s ERP section, and whether a non-renewal or cancellation triggers any rights to buy a tail. Pull your current prior acts date from the declarations page.The ERP provisions, the election deadline and a quote or rate rule for the tail
60 to 90 days beforeRequest proposals. Tell each prospective insurer your current prior acts date and ask for full prior acts credit on a claims-made form, or a quote for an occurrence form.The new policy’s prior acts date, in the proposal and the binder
30 days beforeDecide how the past will be covered: tail from the old insurer, prior acts from the new insurer, or an occurrence form plus a tail. Ask whether any tail would be needed if the new insurer provides full prior acts credit.Which policy responds to a claim about a past incident, named in writing by both insurers
On or before the end dateElect and pay for the tail if you are buying one. Confirm the new policy is effective with no gap, day to day.The tail endorsement and the new policy declarations
Within the stated election window after the end dateIf the tail deadline is short (the specimen allows sixty days), do not wait. Confirm receipt of the request and payment.A written acknowledgment
After the switchFile the old declarations, the tail endorsement and the correspondence with the new policy. Report any incident or claim to the insurer that responds, promptly.A single folder you can find in a year

Worked example, hypothetical

Hypothetical scenario for illustration, not a quote and not a coverage opinion. A two-physician practice has a claims-made policy with a prior acts date four years ago. It moves to a new claims-made policy on the first of a month. If the new policy has the same prior acts date, a claim made in the next year about care given three years ago may fall within the new policy, subject to its terms. If the new policy’s prior acts date is the first of that month, that same claim has no policy to respond, unless the practice bought a tail from the old insurer within the election deadline. The two outcomes depend on one date printed on a declarations page, which is why you ask for it in writing.

If the practice instead moves to an occurrence form, the old claims-made policy’s past is still unprotected after it ends. An occurrence policy covers future events, so the question of the old policy’s past still needs an answer, usually a tail.

Questions to ask an agent

  1. What is the prior acts (retroactive) date on my current policy, and on each proposal you have shown me?
  2. If I leave, can I buy a tail? For how long, by when, and how is the price set?
  3. Does the new insurer give full prior acts credit? Is that stated on the policy or only in an email?
  4. If the new policy has full prior acts credit, do I still need a tail? What do both insurers say about which policy responds to a claim about care before the switch?
  5. Who pays for the tail if the practice employs physicians or I am joining a group? Where is that written in my contract?
  6. Do the policy limits apply per physician, shared across the practice, or include defense costs? (Look at the limits section.)
  7. What is the claim-reporting rule: made, reported, or both? What counts as notice (the specimen counts certain written reports and a request for records)?
  8. Which state endorsement is attached, and does it change the tail terms?

Ask for answers in writing, from the insurer, not only from the agent.

Find an agency

Look for professional liability agencies that work with healthcare practices: healthcare practices and professional liability. Check any agency’s license with our license-check guide before you share practice details. A medical liability program or your state medical association’s program may also be an option; verify its status with your state insurance department.

Frequently asked questions

Do I always need a tail when I leave a claims-made policy?

Not always, but you need something. A tail from the old insurer or full prior acts coverage from the new insurer can each cover past care. If neither applies, past incidents may not be covered. Confirm in writing which one applies, and whether the new policy’s prior acts date matches your old one.

Is the tail the same as nose or prior acts coverage?

No. A tail is bought from the policy you are leaving. Prior acts coverage is written into the new claims-made policy by setting its prior acts date back. Both aim at the same gap, but they come from different insurers and are priced separately.

How long do I have to buy the tail?

It depends on your policy and your state. The specimen policy opened for this guide gives sixty days from when coverage ends for the general ERP and thirty days for some no-additional-premium retirement options. Read your own policy’s ERP section and your state’s requirements.

If I move to an occurrence policy, am I done?

No. The occurrence policy covers events from its start date forward. Care from before it began, under the old claims-made policy, still needs a tail or prior acts arrangement.

Sources

Find professional liability agencies for healthcare practices

0 agencies selected Pick one more