Workers' Comp Premium Audit: Payroll and Subcontractor Checklist
A letter arrives from your workers' compensation insurer: your policy is due for a premium audit, also called a payroll verification. Nothing is wrong. Your premium was based on an estimate of payroll when the policy started, and the insurer now checks what you actually paid. This page gives you a working checklist: which records to pull, who usually holds them, which period they cover, and which gaps to raise with the auditor before they raise them with you. Your notice is the final word on what your insurer wants. The lists below are labeled examples.
Start with your notice, not this page
Every insurer and state fund sets its own record list, deadline and submission method. The checklist below is built from real public examples, but the document that governs your audit is the letter or appointment notice you received. If it asks for something not listed here, follow it. If it is vague, ask the auditor for the list for your policy period in writing.
For background on how payroll becomes premium (classification codes, rates per $100 of payroll, experience rating), see our guide to workers' compensation insurance.
One example: NYSIF's required records list
One example: the NYSIF Required Documents page (New York State Insurance Fund; the matching PDF, What Records Will You Need for an Audit?, is marked 8/21). It applies to NYSIF policyholders. NYSIF says the same list applies whether the verification is done in person, by video meeting or by uploading documents. It asks for these nine items, each with a stated purpose:
- Payroll book or register: to determine gross payroll.
- Payroll tax returns (941, NYS-45, NYS-45 ATT): to verify payroll against detailed payroll records.
- W-2 and W-3 forms: to verify annual payroll.
- 1099 and 1096 forms: to verify other remuneration reported annually.
- Cash book, check book or day book with cash expenses: to find remuneration not reflected in payroll records.
- General ledger: to give an overview of operations.
- Income tax returns (1120/S, 1065, 1040 Schedule C, 990): to verify information from principal sources.
- Certificates of insurance for subcontractors used: to verify subcontractor coverage.
- Contracts, bills and invoices for labor, services and materials: to determine the type of work performed by the policyholder and its subcontractors.
NYSIF adds that for construction, employee leasing or staffing and other businesses that contract out their services, the auditor examines contracts, bills and invoices to verify the nature of the work done by the policyholder or its subcontractors, and that premium charges for employees of uninsured subcontractors are the policyholder's responsibility.
If you are outside New York, do not assume your insurer asks for these exact forms (NYS-45 is a New York filing). The pattern is what carries over: payroll records, the tax filings that confirm them, and proof for anyone who worked for you but was not on payroll.
A second example: other insurers' lists differ
Two more public examples show how much the lists vary.
One example: the State Compensation Insurance Fund (California) page on preparing for your audit, dated August 7, 2025, applies to State Fund policyholders. It names records of contract or day labor (dates and amounts of payments, license numbers, certificates of insurance), Forms 1099 and 1096, job cost records, contracts and invoices, and certified payrolls for wrap-up jobs. It also asks for payroll by employee and classification code, quarterly tax returns, the general ledger, check register and bank statements, a profit and loss statement, and a list of officers, clerical employees and outside salespersons with job duties. Where payroll is split across classifications, it asks for timecards and paystubs for one pay period.
One example: the Beacon Mutual (Rhode Island) premium audit documents page is much shorter. It lists a gross payroll report for the full policy period plus Rhode Island TX-17 and federal 941 filings for the four quarters that match the policy period. It mentions no subcontractor items, which does not mean your auditor will not ask.
The takeaway: a short list from one insurer is not a promise that your auditor will stop there.
Worksheet: records, who keeps them, what they verify
Print this table and fill in the last two columns for your own business. The first three columns reflect the example lists above; "who usually keeps it" is a practical guess you should replace with your own answer.
| Record | Who usually keeps it | Period it should cover | What it helps verify | Your holder / found? (fill in) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Payroll register or payroll provider reports | Owner, bookkeeper or payroll service | Full policy period | Gross payroll, by employee (and by class if your insurer asks) | |
| Quarterly payroll tax returns (federal 941, plus state filings such as NYS-45 or TX-17) | Accountant or payroll service | The quarters that match the policy period (Beacon Mutual names four) | That payroll reported to the insurer matches payroll reported to the tax agencies | |
| W-2 and W-3 | Accountant or payroll service | Tax year(s) overlapping the policy | Annual payroll by employee | |
| 1099 and 1096 | Accountant or bookkeeper | Tax year(s) overlapping the policy | Payments to people who were not on payroll | |
| Check book, cash book or bank statements and check register | Owner or bookkeeper | Full policy period | Pay that never reached the payroll register | |
| General ledger and profit and loss statement | Bookkeeper or accountant | Full policy period | Overall operations; labor and subcontract expense lines | |
| Business income tax return | Accountant | Most recent filed year(s) overlapping the policy | Cross-check of principal figures | |
| Subcontractor certificates of insurance | Owner or office manager; each subcontractor supplies theirs | Must cover the dates the subcontractor worked for you | That each subcontractor carried their own coverage | |
| Subcontract agreements, invoices and bills for labor, services and materials | Owner or office manager | Full policy period | What kind of work was done and by whom | |
| List of owners, officers, members or partners with their pay | Owner | Full policy period | Who is counted, excluded or optional in your state |
Payroll gaps to flag to the auditor
Raise these early, in writing, rather than hoping they go unnoticed. The document list tells you what the auditor will compare, so a mismatch between two records will be seen.
- Payroll register does not match the tax filings. NYSIF says it uses the payroll tax returns to verify payroll from the detailed records. If they differ (late filings, corrections, a payroll service change mid-year), bring the reconciliation, not just the two documents.
- Cash or check payments outside payroll. NYSIF asks for the cash book or check book to find remuneration not reflected in payroll records. If you paid anyone this way, say so and bring the record.
- People paid on a 1099. The 1099 and 1096 are requested to verify other remuneration. Be ready to explain why each person was a contractor and what proof of their own coverage you hold.
- Owners and officers. NYSIF's self-reporting page says owners, officers, members and partners must be listed with gross wages even if excluded from coverage. Your state's rules on who is included or excluded vary, so ask your insurer how it applies to you.
- Mid-year changes in headcount, ownership or duties. California's State Fund page warns that changes to ownership or titles should be reported right away and that large payroll changes should be reported to your broker or underwriter as they happen. Employees whose pay is split between job types can require timecards.
Subcontractor gaps to flag
Check this before the auditor does, because uninsured subcontractors can add premium.
- No certificate of insurance on file. NYSIF states that premium charges for employees of uninsured subcontractors are the policyholder's responsibility. An NCCI state instruction page for Alaska (WCIP State Instructions, effective 1/1/2026) says the same kind of thing for that state: subcontract labor paid without certificates of insurance must be included in the premium calculation. That is one state's rule; check yours.
- Certificate on file, but for the wrong dates. A certificate that expired before the work, or started after it, may not prove coverage for the job. Ask your auditor how they treat a gap.
- Invoices that do not describe the work. NYSIF reviews contracts, bills and invoices to determine the type of work. A vague invoice ("services, $4,000") leaves the auditor guessing. If you can attach a contract or job description, do.
- Subcontractor payments you never recorded as subcontract expense. The general ledger and check register are how auditors find them. California State Fund asks for dates and amounts of contract or day-labor payments.
Exact treatment of subcontractors is set by your state and your insurer. Ask your agent which rules apply before the audit, not after.
How to respond to the notice
- Read the deadline. NYSIF's self-reporting page tells policyholders to complete the payroll verification within 30 days of receiving the notice. Your insurer's deadline may differ.
- Pick the method your insurer offers. NYSIF offers in-person, video and online document upload. California State Fund takes records through its online upload tools.
- Do not ignore it. NYSIF says that if you miss appointments, give insufficient records or do not respond, it may conduct an estimated audit, which could result in higher premium. Its page describes how to avoid one; it does not describe a dispute process, so ask your insurer about yours.
- Have someone available who knows payroll. State Fund suggests a person familiar with operations and payroll be on hand during the audit.
- Keep your own copy of what you submitted and note the date.
Sample email to your agent
If you have an agent, send them the notice before you start gathering records:
Subject: Workers' comp premium audit notice, policy [number]
Hi [name],
We received the attached premium audit notice for the policy period [dates]. Could you confirm: (1) the exact list of records the auditor needs, (2) the deadline and how to submit, (3) how they treat subcontractors who do not have a certificate of insurance on file, and (4) how owners and officers should be reported for our state.
We also paid [number] people on a 1099 and [number] by check outside payroll this period. How should we present those?
Thanks,
[name]
Questions to ask an agent or the auditor
- Which records does my insurer require for this policy period, and in what format?
- Which payroll tax filings should I include for a policy period that does not match the calendar year?
- How are subcontractors without a certificate on file treated, and can I get a certificate after the fact?
- How are owners, officers and LLC members reported on my policy in my state?
- Will the auditor split employee payroll between classification codes, and what proof supports that?
- What happens if I miss the deadline or cannot find a record? Is there a way to correct an estimate later?
Find an agency
If your agent has not helped with the audit, or you are shopping for coverage and want to understand audit exposure up front, browse workers' compensation agencies and agencies serving contractors. Before you sign anything, check the agency's license.
Sources
- NYSIF: Required Documents (policyholder auditing)
- NYSIF: What Records Will You Need for an Audit? (8/21)
- NYSIF: Self-Reporting
- NYSIF: Estimated Audits
- State Compensation Insurance Fund (CA): Preparing for your audit
- Beacon Mutual (RI): Documents required for a premium audit
- NCCI: WCIP State Instructions, Alaska (1/1/2026)