Group Life Insurance for Small Employers: Comparing Two Proposals
You have two group life proposals on the desk and they look similar: a coverage amount, a monthly rate, a carrier name. The part that differs most, and that employees only discover later, is what happens when someone leaves the company.
This guide gives you a worksheet to put the two proposals side by side, a sample email to send the agent, and two real public plan documents to show what the answers can look like. It covers group term life only. For a company-owned policy on a founder, see the separate key person topic; for health benefits, see the small business health guide.
Basic and voluntary: two different benefits
The Bureau of Labor Statistics glossary describes life insurance as a lump-sum payment to the beneficiary of a deceased employee, and notes that employers may provide a basic amount and may also let employees pay for additional amounts. Those two pieces are usually separate parts of a proposal, and they often behave differently.
- Basic (employer-provided) life. A set amount for every eligible employee, such as a multiple of pay or a flat figure. The proposal should say who pays the premium: you, the employee, or both.
- Voluntary (supplemental) life. Extra coverage employees choose and usually pay for. The proposal should say how much can be elected without health questions and how much needs evidence of insurability.
BLS counts access and participation separately: an employee has access when a plan is available to use, even if they decline. In its March 2025 survey, 42 percent of private industry workers in establishments with fewer than 100 workers had access to life insurance plans. That is access, not what any plan costs or pays, so use it only as context for how common the benefit is.
Worksheet: compare the two proposals side by side
Fill in one column per proposal from the written quote and sample certificate, not from a phone call. If a cell is blank, that is a question for the agent.
| Item | Proposal A | Proposal B |
|---|---|---|
| Carrier and form number of the certificate | ||
| Who is eligible (hours per week, waiting period, owners, part-timers) | ||
| Basic amount (flat, or multiple of pay; minimum and maximum) | ||
| Who pays basic premium | ||
| Voluntary options and amount allowed without evidence of insurability | ||
| Reductions by age (percent and ages) | ||
| Waiver of premium if an employee becomes disabled (basic, voluntary, or both) | ||
| Accelerated benefit for terminal illness | ||
| Accidental death rider included or separate | ||
| Conversion right: which events qualify, maximum amount, deadline | ||
| Portability: offered or not, maximum amount, deadline, who bills | ||
| What happens to coverage if the employee stops paying a contribution | ||
| What happens if you change carriers or end the plan | ||
| Rate guarantee period (how long the rate is fixed) |
For the broader habit of comparing quotes line by line, see How to Compare Two Business Insurance Proposals.
When employment ends: stop, convert or port
Group life belongs to the group policy, not to the employee. When someone resigns, is laid off or is fired, a typical certificate says the coverage ends and then offers, at most, one or two ways to continue it. The two terms matter:
- Conversion means turning the group coverage into an individual policy, generally without a health exam, at rates set for that person.
- Portability means continuing the group-style term coverage by paying the insurer directly. Not every plan has it, and where it exists it often applies only to certain parts of the coverage.
The details are written into each certificate, so the only reliable way to compare is to read the section titled something like Termination, Conversion Right or Portability in each proposal's sample certificate. The two public documents below show how much those sections can differ.
One example: how two real certificates answer the same question
These are not small-business plans. They are public-employer certificates, chosen because they are posted openly and show the provisions in full. Treat them as examples of what to look for, not as what any insurer will offer you.
| Basic life: State of Tennessee | Voluntary life: City of San Antonio | |
|---|---|---|
| Document | Group term life certificate, Minnesota Life, plan effective Dec. 1, 2025 | Voluntary term life booklet, Fort Dearborn Life (Texas), rev. 2019 |
| Coverage amount | One times annual earnings, with a stated minimum and maximum, reduced at ages 65, 70 and 75 | Employee elects a multiple of earnings up to a stated cap; amounts reduce at stated ages |
| Conversion when employment ends | Yes, up to the full terminated amount, to an individual policy other than term; apply and pay the first premium within 31 days; no evidence of insurability | Yes, up to the amount in force; written application and first premium within 31 days; individual policy is whole life |
| Conversion if the whole group policy ends | Limited: only after five years of coverage and capped at a small stated amount | Limited: only after five years and capped at a small stated amount |
| When conversion is not available | If coverage ended because a required premium contribution was not paid | Not stated in the same terms; read the Conversion section |
| Portability | None in this certificate | Yes, for the voluntary coverage, with a stated maximum, a one-year minimum time insured, and a 31-day application window; it ends at age 75 or if premiums are not paid |
| Extra features that can drop away | Waiver of premium applies to basic life; the individual policy includes no supplemental benefits | Waiver of premium and accelerated benefit are not available if the disability or terminal illness begins after portability starts |
Three practical lessons come out of this pair. First, the 31-day window is short, and an employee who has just been let go may not know it exists. Second, an individual conversion policy is a different product with its own price, set by age and class of risk on the conversion date. Third, a feature in the group certificate, such as a disability waiver, may not follow the employee to the new policy.
Both documents are certificates summarizing a specific group policy. Another insurer, another state or a newer form may say something different, so read the form you are actually being offered.
Sample email to the agent
Send this, adjusted to your names, before you decide. A written reply is easier to compare than a call.
Subject: Group life proposals: questions before we decide
Hello [Agent name],
We are comparing your group life proposal with another. For each plan, please send the sample certificate with its form number and tell us in writing:
1. What amount is basic, who pays for it, and what is the age-reduction schedule?
2. For voluntary coverage, how much can an employee elect without evidence of insurability, and what deadline applies after hire?
3. When an employee leaves, can the coverage be converted, ported, or neither? What are the maximum amounts and the exact deadlines?
4. Is there any case where conversion or portability is refused, such as unpaid contributions?
5. Do waiver of premium and the accelerated benefit apply after conversion or portability?
6. What happens to employees if we change carriers or end the plan?
7. How long is the rate guaranteed, and what could change it at renewal?
Thank you,
[Your name, company]
Questions to ask an agent
- Which part of the proposal is the employer's cost and which is the employee's, and who administers payroll deductions?
- What happens to a covered employee who goes on leave, moves to part-time or becomes ineligible, and how long does coverage continue in each case?
- Who tells departing employees about conversion or portability, and when? Is that notice your responsibility, the insurer's or ours?
- How do the two proposals treat owners and family members who work in the business?
- Are there payroll-tax consequences for us? The IRS says in Publication 15-B that the cost of group-term life coverage beyond $50,000 must be included in an employee's wages. Ask your accountant how that applies to your plan and to owners.
- If we later grow, are there points at which the plan, the rates or the evidence-of-insurability rules change?
Find an agency
Group life is usually sold alongside other employee benefits. Start at the employee benefits agency list. Before you share payroll data with any agency, confirm it is licensed in your state using How to Check an Insurance Agency's License.
Frequently asked questions
Is conversion the same as portability?
No. Conversion changes group coverage into an individual policy, and the two examples above limit it to a permanent-type policy rather than term. Portability keeps term-style coverage going with direct billing. A certificate may offer one, both or neither, and some plans make them mutually exclusive for the same amount, as the San Antonio booklet does. Ask which applies to the basic and voluntary parts separately.
What if an employee dies shortly after leaving?
The Tennessee certificate and the San Antonio booklet each contain a provision paying a death benefit if the insured dies within the 31-day conversion period, in the amount that could have been converted, whether or not an application was filed. That is written in these two documents, not a general rule, so ask whether the same provision is in each proposal.
Can an employee keep coverage if they stop paying their share?
Usually not. The Tennessee certificate ends coverage 31 days after an unpaid premium contribution is due, and states that neither full nor limited conversion is available when coverage ends for that reason. Ask what grace period and reinstatement rules apply to the plan you are considering.
Do I need to offer group life at all?
BLS describes life insurance as an employee benefit that employers may provide, not a requirement. Whether and how to offer it is a business decision; an agent or attorney can tell you about any rules for your state or industry.
Sources
- State of Tennessee: Group Term Life Certificate of Insurance (Minnesota Life, effective Dec. 1, 2025)
- City of San Antonio: Voluntary Term Life Insurance Employee Benefit Booklet (Fort Dearborn Life, rev. 2019)
- BLS: National Compensation Survey Glossary of Employee Benefit Terms
- BLS: Employee Benefits in the United States, March 2025
- IRS: Publication 15-B, Employer's Tax Guide to Fringe Benefits (2026)