Small Business Health Insurance for Your First Employees
You just hired your first employee, or your third, and someone has asked whether the company offers health insurance. You are not required to decide today, but you do need to know your options before you talk to an agent or an insurer. This guide walks through the choices you control (who is eligible, how much you pay, when coverage starts), the three main routes federal sources describe, and a worksheet and sample email you can use to get comparable answers. Rules for plans and agents vary by state, so confirm details with your state insurance department.
Start with the decisions that are yours
Federal guidance for small employers frames group coverage as a set of choices you make before you enroll. HealthCare.gov lists several of them: how much of the premium you pay, how long new employees wait before they get a coverage offer, and whether to offer coverage to dependents and part-time employees. It also notes that you can set your contribution separately for dental plans.
Write your answers down first. An agent or insurer can quote you faster, and you can compare two proposals on the same terms. If you already have two quotes, see How to Compare Two Business Insurance Proposals.
Two details to know early. Dependent coverage is generally optional, but some states require it, so ask your state department of insurance. And an employee may qualify for premium tax credits on their own if your plan is not considered affordable, which HealthCare.gov mentions without spelling out the test on that page. Ask your agent how affordability is measured for your plan.
Three routes to compare
HealthCare.gov's small-business HRA guide compares a group health plan bought through SHOP with two reimbursement arrangements. The table below paraphrases that comparison. Treat it as a map for your questions, not advice on which to pick.
| Route | What it is | Who it is for, per the source | What to ask |
|---|---|---|---|
| Group plan through SHOP | You buy a plan, or a set of plans, from an insurer and offer it to employees. | Generally employers with 1 to 50 full-time equivalent employees. | Which plans, which networks, and what is the monthly enrollment deadline? |
| QSEHRA | A small-employer arrangement that reimburses employees for qualifying medical costs, with an annual cap on what you can provide. | Employers with fewer than 50 workers that do not offer other group coverage. | What is the current annual cap, and how are the written notices handled? |
| CHOICE arrangement (formerly called ICHRA) | An employer reimbursement of individual coverage premiums, with no annual cap on employer contributions. | Employers of any size with at least one employee, other than certain owners and their spouses. | How are contributions set across employee groups, and what notice is required? |
For both reimbursement routes, the source says written notice generally goes to employees 90 days before the plan year begins. If you are close to a start date, that timeline matters.
How SHOP enrollment works
One example: the HealthCare.gov page on enrolling in SHOP is the current federal description of the process for small employers. Its scope is federal SHOP coverage; it does not replace your state's rules or an insurer's own enrollment calendar.
As that page describes it, you first complete an eligibility determination form, which gives instant results. You then enroll either with a SHOP-registered agent or broker or directly with an insurance company. You do not start an application on HealthCare.gov, and you pay premiums to your insurer, not to HealthCare.gov. Keep your eligibility results, because proof may be required to enroll and to claim the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit. Have the plan name, metal level, plan type and plan ID on hand for the plan you pick.
CMS says SHOP is generally open to employers with 1 to 50 full-time equivalent employees, up to 100 in some states, and that you need an office or work site in the state whose SHOP you use. CMS also says employers must cover all full-time or FTE staff, and that in many states a minimum participation rate applies: at least 70 percent of employees offered coverage must accept it. CMS describes an exemption from that rule for employers applying or renewing between November 15 and December 15. Note that CMS's page was last modified in September 2024, so confirm each of these with an insurer or registered agent before relying on them.
To count your full-time equivalents, HealthCare.gov offers an FTE calculator. To find an agent or broker, use HealthCare.gov's local help tool.
The tax credit: check it before you choose
If you have very few employees and modest average pay, you may be eligible for the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit. The IRS says the employer must have fewer than 25 full-time equivalent employees, pay at least half the cost of employee-only coverage, and offer a qualified health plan through SHOP. The credit can cover up to 50 percent of premiums (35 percent for tax-exempt employers), for two consecutive taxable years, and it shrinks as you grow past 10 FTEs or as average wages rise.
HealthCare.gov and the IRS give different average-wage figures on their pages, and the IRS page itself lists inflation-adjusted amounts only through tax year 2023. So do not rely on a number from this guide or any summary. Check the current IRS page and the Form 8941 instructions, and ask your tax preparer. The IRS page is Small Business Health Care Tax Credit and the SHOP Marketplace.
Because the credit is generally tied to enrolling in a SHOP plan, decide this before you sign up for a plan outside SHOP.
Worksheet: write your answers before you call
Print this page and fill in the right-hand column. Then give the same answers to every agent or insurer so the quotes line up.
| Decision | Your answer |
|---|---|
| Number of full-time employees, and part-time hours per week for each part-timer | |
| Do owners or family members count as covered employees? (ask the insurer) | |
| Percent of employee-only premium you will pay | |
| Offer dependent coverage? Contribution toward it? | |
| Dental coverage? Separate contribution? | |
| Waiting period before a new hire gets an offer | |
| Desired coverage start date, and the insurer's enrollment deadline | |
| Office or work site state(s) | |
| Eligibility form results saved? Tax credit questions for your preparer |
Questions to ask an agent or insurer
- Are you a SHOP-registered agent or broker, and which insurers can you quote in my state?
- Do I qualify under my state's employee-count rules, and how do you count part-timers?
- Is there a minimum participation rate, and what happens if too few employees accept?
- What is the monthly enrollment deadline, and when does coverage start after I enroll?
- Is the plan considered affordable for my lowest-paid employee, and how is that measured?
- What does the proposal assume about my contribution, and what changes if I change it?
- Which plan documents and employee notices will I receive, and who delivers them?
- If I want the tax credit, what proof will I need to keep?
For the difference between agents, brokers and captive agents, see Insurance Agent vs. Broker. If you are weighing paperwork, the Printable Quote Preparation Checklist covers general business insurance documents.
A sample email to send
Copy, fill in the brackets and send to two or three agents or insurers.
Subject: Group health quote request for [Business name], [State]
Hello [Name], we are a [type of business] with [number] full-time employees and [number] part-time employees, working out of [city, state]. We are considering offering group health coverage for the first time.
We expect to pay [percent] of employee-only premiums, [dependent coverage plan], and a waiting period of [period]. We would like coverage to start on [date].
Could you tell us which plans you can quote, your enrollment deadline, any minimum participation requirement, and what documents we need? We would also like to know whether our business qualifies for the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit, or whether we should ask our tax preparer. Please include your license number.
Thank you, [Name, phone]
After you enroll: the paperwork is real
Once you offer a plan, you take on administrative duties. The Department of Labor's EBSA publishes guidance on the responsibilities of those who manage a group health plan, including participant disclosures. Ask your insurer or agent which notices and filings apply to your plan size, and read the DOL guide on group health plan fiduciary responsibilities. Do not assume the insurer handles everything for you.
Find an agency
Browse employee benefits agencies to find agencies that list group benefits. Before you share employee information, check that the agent holds a license in your state using our guide, How to Check an Insurance Agency's License. If you are a solo owner with no employees, see the HealthCare.gov self-employed coverage page instead.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to go through HealthCare.gov to buy SHOP coverage?
No. HealthCare.gov says you will not start an application there. You complete an eligibility form, then enroll with an insurance company or a SHOP-registered agent or broker, and you pay premiums to the insurer.
Can I choose how much of the premium I pay?
HealthCare.gov says you choose how much of employees' premiums you cover, and you can set it separately for dental plans. If you want the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit, the IRS requires you to pay at least half of the cost of employee-only coverage.
Do I have to offer coverage to dependents and part-timers?
HealthCare.gov lists both as choices you make, and says dependent coverage is generally optional though some states require it. CMS says employers must cover all full-time or FTE staff. Confirm part-time rules with your insurer.
What if only a few employees want the plan?
CMS says many states set a minimum participation rate, with at least 70 percent of employees offered coverage required to accept it. An exemption applies to applications or renewals between November 15 and December 15. Ask your agent about your state.
Sources
- HealthCare.gov: Small business health insurance
- HealthCare.gov: Get coverage for your small business (SHOP)
- HealthCare.gov: Enroll in SHOP
- HealthCare.gov: Small business health care tax credit
- HealthCare.gov: HRA guide for small employers
- HealthCare.gov: FTE calculator
- HealthCare.gov: Find local help
- HealthCare.gov: Self-employed coverage options
- CMS: Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP)
- IRS: Small Business Health Care Tax Credit and the SHOP Marketplace
- DOL EBSA: Understanding your fiduciary responsibilities under a group health plan