Short-Term vs. Long-Term Disability: Employer Checklist
You are an employer deciding whether to offer disability coverage, or you have two quotes on the desk and the quotes use different words for the same things. This page gives you a worksheet to put short-term disability (STD) and long-term disability (LTD) side by side, and shows where the terms actually sit in two real group certificates so you know what to ask for. It is for employers choosing or reviewing a group plan. It is not a guide to filing an individual claim, and it does not tell you what any plan would pay you.
What the two plans are for
Both plans replace part of an employee's pay when an illness or injury that is not work-related keeps them from working. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics describes short-term plans as paying per disability for roughly 6 to 12 months, and long-term plans as paying monthly benefits to employees who cannot work for an extended time, starting after a waiting period or after other benefits end (BLS, The Economics Daily, December 2020).
Work-related injuries are a separate system. If that is your question, read our workers' compensation guide instead.
In practice the two plans are built to hand off to each other: STD covers the early weeks, and LTD begins when STD ends. The most common employer mistake is buying or reviewing each plan alone and leaving a gap or an overlap between them. The worksheet below is built around that handoff.
The comparison worksheet
Print this and fill in one column per quote. Every row is something the plan document defines, so the answer is in the certificate, not in a sales summary. Ask for the certificate (the plan booklet your employees would receive) or a specimen of it before you decide.
| Question | Short-term disability | Long-term disability | Where to find it in the certificate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waiting period before benefits start (may be called benefit waiting period or elimination period) | ______ days | ______ days | Coverage features or schedule of insurance |
| Does the waiting period differ for injury vs. illness? | Yes / No | Yes / No | Schedule of insurance |
| How long do benefits last (maximum benefit period)? | ______ weeks / days | ______ years, or to age ______ | Schedule of insurance |
| Does the STD end date match the LTD start date? | STD ends day ______; LTD starts day ______; gap or overlap: ______ | Both schedules | |
| Percentage of pay replaced, and the monthly or weekly cap | ______ % / cap ______ | ______ % / cap ______ | Schedule of insurance |
| Which pay counts (base only, bonus, commission)? | ______ | ______ | Definition of predisability earnings |
| Definition of disability: own occupation, any occupation, or both, and for how long | ______ | ______ | Definition of disability |
| Partial or residual disability covered? | Yes / No | Yes / No | Definition of disability; return-to-work provisions |
| Pre-existing condition limit | ______ | ______ | Exclusions and limitations |
| Mental health or other limits and exclusions | ______ | ______ | Exclusions and limitations |
| Benefits reduced by other income (Social Security, sick pay, other plans)? | ______ | ______ | Deductible income |
| Who pays the premium: employer, employee, or shared? | ______ | ______ | Premium contributions |
| Who is eligible (hours worked, waiting period for new hires, active-work rule)? | ______ | ______ | Becoming insured |
| Deadline to file proof of loss | ______ | ______ | Claims section |
One example: what two real certificates say
Group certificates are written by the insurer, and the same words can mean different things in different plans. Here is where the worksheet's rows land in two published certificates from the same insurer. Treat them as one example each, not as typical terms, and do not assume your plan looks like either.
Short-term example. This is the Standard Insurance Company Group Short Term Disability certificate for Larimer County, Colorado (policy 758982-C, group effective January 1, 2021, certificate revised February 24, 2026). It states a benefit waiting period of 14 days for both accidental injury and for illness, pregnancy or mental disorder, a maximum benefit period of 76 days, and a benefit of 60% of the first $3,333 of predisability earnings, capped at $2,000 before reductions. The insurance is noncontributory, which means the employer pays. STD benefits also end on the date long-term disability benefits become payable under an employer group plan, even if that is before the 76 days are up. Its definition of disability is an own-job test: the employee must be unable to perform the material duties of their own job and lose at least 20% of predisability earnings. Notice how much of the worksheet is answered by this one schedule page.
Long-term example. This is the Standard Insurance Company Group Long Term Disability certificate for the City of Seattle (policy 608217-B, group effective June 1, 1992, schedule dated March 5, 2012). It is a public-employer plan and an older document, so use it to see the structure, not the numbers. It has a 90-day benefit waiting period; a benefit of 60% of insured predisability earnings reduced by deductible income, with two plan options at different caps; a maximum benefit period set by the employee's age when disability begins (for an employee 61 or younger, to age 65, to Social Security normal retirement age, or 3 years 6 months, whichever is longest); and an own-occupation period of the first 24 months of benefits, after which the test becomes any occupation. It also has a pre-existing condition exclusion and a full Social Security offset, and the higher plan option is paid for by the employee.
Put the two side by side and you can see the handoff. In the first, STD stops when LTD benefits become payable. In the second, the LTD waiting period is 90 days. If your STD plan lasts a fixed number of days and your LTD waiting period is longer, there is a stretch where nothing is paying. Ask both insurers, and your agent, how the dates line up for your own plan.
Terms that change the answer
- Waiting period. Some certificates call it a benefit waiting period, others an elimination period. Some plans use a longer period for the first year of coverage, as the Larimer certificate does for coverage that is not employer-paid.
- Own occupation vs. any occupation. Under an own-occupation test the employee qualifies if they cannot do their own job. Under an any-occupation test they must be unable to do any gainful work they are reasonably fitted for. Many LTD plans start with the first and switch to the second after a set period, as the Seattle certificate does after 24 months of benefits. This is one of the most important rows in the worksheet.
- Own job vs. own occupation. The two examples above define own occupation differently. The STD example ties it to the job the employee regularly performs for you. The LTD example says own occupation is not limited to the job with your company. The same phrase, a different meaning.
- Offsets. Both examples reduce the benefit by other income, including Social Security and, in the LTD example, sick pay or other salary continuation. If your company already provides paid sick leave, ask how the plan treats it.
- Pre-existing conditions. The LTD example excludes conditions treated in a look-back window before coverage starts, for a set number of months. Ask for the exact window.
- Contributory vs. noncontributory. Who pays affects both cost and how many employees enroll. BLS reported in 2020 that most workers with these benefits did not have to contribute: 15% of workers had a contribution requirement for STD and 6% for LTD.
How common is this benefit
BLS National Compensation Survey data as of March 2020 showed that 40% of civilian workers had access to short-term disability insurance and 35% had access to long-term disability. Access rose with pay: for the lowest-paid quarter of workers it was 19% (STD) and 9% (LTD), and for the highest-paid quarter 55% and 59%. These are national figures for all employers and say nothing about what you need, but they tell you what employees in a competitive hiring market may expect.
Questions to ask an agent or insurer
- Can I have the full certificate or a specimen, not just a benefit summary?
- On what day does STD end and LTD begin for a typical disability, and is there any gap?
- How is the definition of disability worded, and when does it change?
- What counts as earnings for the benefit calculation, and is the cap monthly or weekly?
- What does the plan subtract for other income, including our own sick leave or paid time off policy?
- What is the pre-existing condition window, and does it apply to new hires who enroll late?
- What happens to an employee on leave when they come back part time?
- What proof of loss is required, and how long does the employee have to file?
- If we change carriers, what happens to employees who are already disabled?
- Does our state or any other law add requirements for us, separate from this plan? (Ask your state labor or insurance department; do not assume.)
You can send the questions as a message:
Subject: Group STD and LTD quote: certificate request
We are comparing group short-term and long-term disability coverage for about [number] employees in [state]. Could you send the full certificate (or a specimen) for each plan, not just the summary?
Please also tell us: the benefit waiting period for injury and for illness, the maximum benefit period, the date the short-term benefit ends and the long-term benefit starts, how disability is defined and when the definition changes, what reduces the benefit, the pre-existing condition window, and whether employees or the company pay the premium.
Thank you.
[Name, company, phone]
Where this fits and what to do next
Disability insurance is one part of an employee benefits package, usually handled by an agent who works with group plans. See our guide to health insurance for your first employees and the finder for employee benefits. A group life plan is a separate product; see our guide to compare the two.
To compare two quotes in general, use How to Compare Two Business Insurance Proposals.
Find an agency
Browse employee benefits agencies and ask each one for specimen certificates before you compare prices. Before you work with any agency, check its license and your state's rules using How to Check an Insurance Agency's License in Your State.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need both short-term and long-term disability?
They cover different time spans, and many employers offer both so the plans hand off to each other. Neither one is required by the documents reviewed for this page. Whether you need one, both or neither depends on your state's rules and your workforce, so ask a licensed agent and your state regulator.
Is disability insurance the same as workers' compensation?
No. BLS describes these plans as covering illnesses or injuries that are not work-related. Work injuries go through workers' compensation, which is a separate system with its own rules by state.
Why do two plans with the same percentage pay differently?
The percentage is only one row. The cap, which earnings count, offsets for other income, the waiting period and the definition of disability can each change the result. In the Larimer STD example the 60% applies only to the first $3,333 of earnings and is capped at $2,000.
Does STD end when LTD begins?
In the Larimer STD certificate, yes: STD benefits end on the date long-term benefits become payable under an employer group plan. Your plan may differ, so confirm the wording in both certificates.
Sources
- BLS: Short-term and long-term disability insurance for civilian workers in 2020
- Standard Insurance Company: Group Short Term Disability certificate, Larimer County, Colorado (policy 758982-C, revised 2/24/2026), hosted by Larimer County
- Standard Insurance Company: Group Long Term Disability certificate, City of Seattle (policy 608217-B), hosted by the City of Seattle